↑ อ้างอิงผิดพลาด: ป้ายระบุ <ref> ไม่ถูกต้อง ไม่มีการกำหนดข้อความสำหรับอ้างอิงชื่อ Casualties and losses
อ้างอิง
Zetterling & Frankson 2000, p. 108, Excerpt reads: "If we take a look at how the front lines changed during these five days one could interpret it as some sort of success for the Germans ... However, if we compare the outcome with the German orders for the battle, which stated that Prokhorovka was the target, it is clear that the Germans fell short of their goals. The Red Army had hoped to push the II SS-Panzer Corps back and crush it. This failed completely, but at least the 5th Guards Tank Army prevented the Germans from taking Prokhorovka."none
Zamulin 2011, p. 561, Excerpt reads: "The counterattack [at Prokhorovka] did not achieve its basic goal. The [II SS-Panzer Corps] was not routed, but the further advance of the II SS-Panzer Corps beyond Prokhorovka was finally halted."none
Healy 2008, p. 347, Excerpt reads: "The clash was, when set against the much wider strategic backdrop of the offensive, no more than a local, tactical German victory. It was of no consequence or significance in helping to realise any of the wider offensive objectives of Operation Zitadelle, which was in any case by this date already a failure."none
Clark 2012, p. 408, Excerpt reads: "Even though II SS-Panzer Corps could claim to have won a tactical victory in the monumental armoured clash at Prokhorovka ... Hausser's men did not do enough to change the course of the operation."none
Showalter 2013, p. 269, Excerpt reads: "The Waffen-SS won a tactical victory on July 12."none
Nipe 2012, p. 86, Excerpt reads: "The small expansion of the Psel bridgehead by Totenkopf and the advances of Das Reich around the southern edges of Prochorovka were tactical victories at best and not decisive by any definition."none
Showalter 2013, p. 269, Excerpt reads: "Operationally, however, the palm rests with the Red Army."none
Zamulin 2011, p. 553, Excerpt reads: "The main task of a defender is to repulse an enemy attack ... A decisive breakthrough is what von Manstein had planned for 12 July via a regrouping of his forces. The [II SS-Panzer Corps] did not achieve this goal. Thus in sum, the forces of the Voronezh Front won the engagement at Prokhorovka, and then successfully completed the defensive operation, having created the conditions for a decisive counteroffensive."none
Glantz & House 2004, p. 272, Excerpt reads: "The numerous flank attacks orchestrated by the [Soviets] sapped the German strength, ..., permitted the timely arrival of Soviet operational and strategic reserves, and led directly to Soviet victory at Prokhorovka, in particular, and in Citadel as a whole."none
ตุลาคม 12, 2021
ทธการท, โปรโฮรอฟกา, เป, นการส, รบเม, อว, นท, กรกฎาคม, 1943, ใกล, บโปรโฮรอฟกา, โลเมตร, ไมล, ทางตอนใต, ของเม, องค, สค, ในสหภาพโซเว, ยต, ในช, วงสงครามโลกคร, งท, สอง, เก, ดข, นบนแนวรบด, านตะว, นออก, การส, รบคร, งน, เป, นส, วนหน, งของย, ทธการท, สค, กว, างขวาง, และเ. yuththkarthioprohrxfka epnkarsurbemuxwnthi 12 krkdakhm kh s 1943 a iklkboprohrxfka 87 kiolemtr 54 iml thangtxnitkhxngemuxngkhuskhinshphaphosewiyt inchwngsngkhramolkkhrngthisxng ekidkhunbnaenwrbdantawnxxk karsurbkhrngniepnswnhnungkhxngyuththkarthikhuskhthikwangkhwang aelaekidkhunemuxkxngthphrththngkardthi 5 khxngkxngthphaedngaehngshphaphosewiytidekhaocmtiehlaaephnesxr exsexsthi 2 khxngkxngthphewrmkhthaehngeyxrmn inhnungkhxngkarsurbbnrththngthikhnadihythisudinprawtisastrthangkarthharyuththkarthioprohrxfkaswnhnungkhxng yuththkarthikhuskhbnaenwrbdantawnxxkkhxngsngkhramolkkhrngthisxngrththngeyxrmninchwngptibtikarsithaedlwnthi12 krkdakhm kh s 1943 a sthanthioprohrxfka osewiytrsesiy shphaphosewiyt 51 2 11 N 36 44 11 E 51 03639 N 36 73639 E 51 03639 36 73639 phikdphumisastr 51 2 11 N 36 44 11 E 51 03639 N 36 73639 E 51 03639 36 73639phlthngsxngfaytanglmehlwinkarbrrluepahmaykhxngphwkekha 1 2 eyxrmnidrbchychnathangyuththsastr 3 4 5 6 osewiytidrbchychnainptibtikar 7 8 9 khusngkhram ircheyxrmn shphaphosewiytphubngkhbbychaaelaphunaHermann Hoth phxl ehaesxrOtto DesslochNikolai Vatutin Pavel Rotmistrov Alexei ZhadovStepan Krasovsky Vladimir SudetshnwythiekiywkhxngII SS Panzer Corps 1st SS Panzergrenadier Division Leibstandarte SS Adolf Hitler 2nd SS Panzergrenadier Division Das Reich 3rd SS Panzergrenadier Division Totenkopf5th Guards Tank Army b 29th Tank Corps 18th Tank Corps 2nd Guards Tank Corps c 2nd Tank Corps d 5th Guards Mechanized Corps e Other units 33rd Guards Rifle Corps f 10th Tank Corps g 31st Tank Corps 23rd Guards Rifle Corps h 48th Rifle CorpskalngGerman About 290 tanks and assault guns i Soviet About 610 tanks and self propelled guns i khwamsuyesiyGerman on 12 July 43 80 tanks and assault guns destroyed or damaged j Soviet on 12 July 300 400 tanks and self propelled guns destroyed or damaged j Location of Prokhorovka within modern Russiaaemaebb Campaignbox Axis Soviet War aemaebb Campaignbox Kursk ineduxnemsayn kh s 1943 phunafayeyxrmniderimetriymkhwamphrxmsahrbptibtikarsithaedl wtthuprasngkhkhxngkaroxblxmaelathalaykxngthphosewiytinswnthiyudxxkkhxngkhuskh odyocmtiaelathalayphanthanthphkhxngswnthiyudxxkcakthangehnuxaelathangitphrxmkn karrukkhxngeyxrmnidekidkhwamlachahlaykhrngenuxngcakkhwamlngelinkarepnphunaaelakarephimetimkxngkalngaelakaridrbxawuthyuothpkrnihm kxngbychakarradbsungkhxngosewiyt stafkha Stavka idrbruthungkhwamtngickhxngeyxrmn aeladngnncungichkhwamlachainkaretriymkhwamphrxmsahrbkarsrangaenwpxngkntamesnthangkhxngaephnkarrukrankhxngeyxrmnthiidkahndiw phunafayosewiytyngidrwbrwmhlaykxngthphmaxyuinhlngaenwpxngknkhuxkxnghnunstafkha Stavka Reserve kxngthphklumni aenwrbsetppepnkarepidchakkarocmtitxbot emuxkhwamaekhngaekrngkhxngeyxrmnidxxnkalnglng kxngthphrththngkardthi 5 epnhnwyyanekraahlkthikxtngkhunkhxngaenwrbsetppemuxwnthi 5 krkdakhm kh s 1943 kxngthphewrmkhidepidchakkarrukran bnthangtxnehnuxkhxngswnthiyudxxk kxngkalngeyxrmnidhyudchangklngphayinsiwn bnthangtxnit kxngthphaephnesxrthi 4 kbkxngthph Detachment Kempf khxngeyxrmnbnpikfngtawnxxk idekhacuocmkarpxngknosewiytkhxngaenwrboworench phwkekhaidmikhwamlachaaetkawekhaipxyangxyangtxenuxngphanaenwpxngknosewiytphayhlngspdahkhxngkarsurb osewiytidepidchakkarocmtiotklbkhxngphwkekha ptibtikarkhutusxfbnthangtxnehnuxaelapracwbehmaakbthangtxnit bnthangtxnitkhxngswnthiyudxxkxyuiklkboprohrxfka kxngthphrththngkardthi 5 idephchiyhnakbehlaaephnesxr exsexsthi 2 khxngkxngthphaephnesxrthi 4 sngphlthaihmikarpathaknkhxngyanekraakhnadihy kxngthphrththngkardthi 5 idprasbkhwamsuyesiykxngkalngthisakhyinkarcuocm aetidprasbkhwamsaercinkarpxngknkxngthphewrmkhthcakkarekhayudkhrxngoprohrxfka aelathalayphanaenwpxngknsamaehng sudthaykidrbkaresrimkalngxyanghnk kxngbychakarradbsungeyxrmn imsamarthbrrluwtthuprasngkh cungtdsinicykelikptibtikarsithaedl aelaerimoykyaykalngphlkhxngkxngkalngephuxcdkarkbkarphthnaihm xyangkrachnchidcakthixun kxngthphaedngtxngkarkarrukaebbsamy dwykardaeninptibtikar Polkovodets Rumyantsev bnthangtxnitaelaptibtikarkhutusxfiddaeninipxyangtxenuxnginbnthangtxnehnux shphaphosewiytidyudkhwamkhidrierimthangyuththsastrbnaenwrbdantawnxxk sungcatxngichewlathiehluxkhxngsngkhramhmayehtu aekikh 1 0 1 1 xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux Date of the Battle xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 5th GTA xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 2nd GTC xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 2nd TC xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 5th GMC xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 5th GA xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 10th TC xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux 23rd GRC 9 0 9 1 xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux Opposing forces 10 0 10 1 xangxingphidphlad payrabu lt ref gt imthuktxng immikarkahndkhxkhwamsahrbxangxingchux Casualties and lossesxangxing aekikh Zetterling amp Frankson 2000 p 108 Excerpt reads If we take a look at how the front lines changed during these five days one could interpret it as some sort of success for the Germans However if we compare the outcome with the German orders for the battle which stated that Prokhorovka was the target it is clear that the Germans fell short of their goals The Red Army had hoped to push the II SS Panzer Corps back and crush it This failed completely but at least the 5th Guards Tank Army prevented the Germans from taking Prokhorovka none Zamulin 2011 p 561 Excerpt reads The counterattack at Prokhorovka did not achieve its basic goal The II SS Panzer Corps was not routed but the further advance of the II SS Panzer Corps beyond Prokhorovka was finally halted none Healy 2008 p 347 Excerpt reads The clash was when set against the much wider strategic backdrop of the offensive no more than a local tactical German victory It was of no consequence or significance in helping to realise any of the wider offensive objectives of Operation Zitadelle which was in any case by this date already a failure none Clark 2012 p 408 Excerpt reads Even though II SS Panzer Corps could claim to have won a tactical victory in the monumental armoured clash at Prokhorovka Hausser s men did not do enough to change the course of the operation none Showalter 2013 p 269 Excerpt reads The Waffen SS won a tactical victory on July 12 none Nipe 2012 p 86 Excerpt reads The small expansion of the Psel bridgehead by Totenkopf and the advances of Das Reich around the southern edges of Prochorovka were tactical victories at best and not decisive by any definition none Showalter 2013 p 269 Excerpt reads Operationally however the palm rests with the Red Army none Zamulin 2011 p 553 Excerpt reads The main task of a defender is to repulse an enemy attack A decisive breakthrough is what von Manstein had planned for 12 July via a regrouping of his forces The II SS Panzer Corps did not achieve this goal Thus in sum the forces of the Voronezh Front won the engagement at Prokhorovka and then successfully completed the defensive operation having created the conditions for a decisive counteroffensive none Glantz amp House 2004 p 272 Excerpt reads The numerous flank attacks orchestrated by the Soviets sapped the German strength permitted the timely arrival of Soviet operational and strategic reserves and led directly to Soviet victory at Prokhorovka in particular and in Citadel as a whole noneekhathungcak https th wikipedia org w index php title yuththkarthioprohrxfka amp oldid 9493415, wikipedia, วิกิ หนังสือ, หนังสือ, ห้องสมุด,
