วิธีโดนต์นั้นแตกต่างกันตรงสูตรคำนวณในการหาผลหาร ซึ่งเมื่อใช้สูตรนี้แทน พรรค A จะได้รับ 4 ที่นั่ง ในขณะที่พรรค D ไม่ได้เลย ซึ่งแสดงให้เห็นถึงความได้เปรียบของพรรคการเมืองใหญ่ที่คะแนนเสียงมาก
อ้างอิง
↑ Lijphart, Arend (2003), "Degrees of proportionality of proportional representation formulas", ใน Grofman, Bernard; Lijphart, Arend (บ.ก.), Electoral Laws and Their Political Consequences, Agathon series on representation, 1, Algora Publishing, pp. 170–179, ISBN9780875862675 See in particular the section "Sainte-Lague", pp. 174–175.
For example with three seats, a 55-25-20 vote is seen to be more proportionally represented by an allocation of 1-1-1 seats than by 2-1-0.
Balinski, Michel L.; Peyton, Young (1982). Fair Representation: Meeting the Ideal of One Man, One Vote.
"New votes-to-seats system makes elections 'fairer'". The Jakarta Post. 28 May 2018. สืบค้นเมื่อ 19 April 2019.
Ireland's Green Party website
"House of Lords Reform Draft Bill" (PDF). Cabinet Office. May 2011. p. 16.
(PDF). Electoral Commission https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/sites/default/files/pdf_file/Distribution-of-UK-MEPs-among-electoral-regions.pdf. สืบค้นเมื่อ 21 December 2019. Missing or empty |title= (help)
"European Parliament (Number of MEPs and Distribution between Electoral Regions) (United Kingdom and Gibraltar) Order 2008 - Hansard". hansard.parliament.uk.
http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//NONSGML+IM-PRESS+20070604IPR07417+EN+DOC+PDF+V0//EN&language=EN. Missing or empty |title= (help)
McLean, Iain (1 November 2008). "Don't let the lawyers do the math: Some problems of legislative districting in the UK and the USA". Mathematical and Computer Modelling. 48 (9): 1446–1454. doi:10.1016/j.mcm.2008.05.025. ISSN 0895-7177.
Miller, Nicholas R. (February 2013), "Election inversions under proportional representation", Annual Meeting of the Public Choice Society, New Orleans, March 8-10, 2013(PDF).
สิงหาคม 08, 2021
เว, บสเตอร, แซ, งต, ลาก, งกฤษ, webster, sainte, laguë, method, หร, อน, ยมเร, ยกส, เว, บสเตอร, หร, แซ, งต, ลาก, เป, นว, การคำนวณหาค, าเฉล, ยส, งส, ดสำหร, บการจ, ดสรรป, นส, วนท, งในระบบส, ดส, วนแบบบ, ญช, รายช, อซ, งใช, ในระบบการลงคะแนนหลายระบบ, ในย, โรปต, งช, อต. withiewbsetxr aesngt lakuw xngkvs Webster Sainte Lague method hruxniymeriyksn wa withiewbsetxr hrux withiaesngt lakuw epnwithikarkhanwnhakhaechliysungsudsahrbkarcdsrrpnswnthinnginrabbsdswnaebbbychiraychuxsungichinrabbkarlngkhaaennhlayrabb inyuorptngchuxtamxxngedr aesngt lakuw nkkhnitsastrchawfrngess swninshrthtngchuxtamaedeniyl ewbsetxr rthburusaelawuthismachik withinikhlaykbwithiodntaetichtwharthitangkn inkrniswnihyinwithiehluxesssungsudsungichokhwtaaehridphllphththiekuxbcaehmuxnkn withiodntihphllphththikhlaykndwy aetchwyihphrrkhihyidepriybkwaemuxethiybkbwithiewbsetxr aesngt lakuw 1 withiewbsetxr aesngt lakuwthukmxngwaepnwithithiepnsdswnkwa aetyngmikhwamesiyngthicathaihphrrkhkaremuxngthiidkhaaennesiyngmakkwakhrunghnungaetsamarthidthinngnxykwakhrunghnungkhxngspha 2 odymakcamieknthkhaaennesiyngkhntasungemuxkxncacdsrrthinngidphrrkhkaremuxngcatxngidrbcanwnkhaaennesiyngxyangnxycanwnhnungewbsetxridesnxwithiniin kh s 1832 aela kh s 1842 sungidthukichinkarcdsrrthinngihkbsphakhxngekrs aelatxmaidthukaethnthidwywithiaehmiltn aelain kh s 1911 withiewbsetxridthuknaklbmaichxikkhrnghnung 3 txmain kh s 1940 cungthukepliynmaichwithihntingtn hill infrngess xxngedr aesngt lakuw idklawthungwithiniinbthkhwamkhxngekhain kh s 1910 odykhadwafrngessaelayuorpnnimrbruthungwithiewbsetxrcnkrathngsngkhramolkkhrngthisxngcblngwithiewbsetxr aesngt lakuwichinkhxsxwx nxrewy niwsiaelnd bxseniyaelaehxresokwina ltewiy swiedn aelaxirk ineyxrmniichinradbrthsphaklangsahrbbunedisthakh aelainradbrthnnichinkareluxktngsphanitibyytiinrthchelswich hxlchitn rthnxrthirn ewsthfaelin rthbaedin ewuxrthethimaebrkh rthirnlnth flths ebremin aelahmbwrkh inednmarkichinkarcdsrrthinngcanwn 40 thinngcakthnghmd 179 thinnginrthsphaednmark odyichesrimkbwithiodntnxkcakniinxdityngekhyichinobliewiyin kh s 1993 opaelndin kh s 2001 aelainsphanitibyytipaelsitnin kh s 2006 nxkcakniwithixunthikhlayknsungeriykwa withiaesngt lakuwaebbprbaetng modified Sainted Lague idthukichinkarcdsrrpnswnthinnginrabbsdswnkhxngkareluxktngthwipinenpal kh s 2008 aelayngichwithiediywknniinkareluxktnginxinodniesiyin kh s 2019 4 withiniyngidrbkaresnxodyphrrkhkrininixraelndephuxichinkarptirupephuxichinkareluxktngsphalang 5 aelaichodyrthbalphsmxnurksniymaelaesriprachathipitykhxngshrachxanackrin kh s 2011 ephuxichepnwithikhanwnkarcdsrrthinnginkareluxktngsphakhunnang 6 khnakrrmkarkareluxktngkhxngshrachxanackridichwithiniin kh s 2003 2007 2010 aela 2013 ephuxcdsrrthinngkhxngshrachxanackrinsphayuorpinthanakhxngekhteluxktngshrachxanackraelaphumiphakhxngkvs 7 8 odykthmaysphayuorp kh s 2003 byytiihaetlaphumiphakhcatxngidrbxyangnxy 3 thinng aelaxtraswnkhxngphuaethntxthinngcatxngekuxbethakninaetlaphumiphakh odykhnakrrmkarehnwawithiaesngt lakuwnnthaihidkhaebiyngebnmatrthannxythisudemuxepriybethiybkbwithiodnt aelaokhwtaaehr 9 10 karkhanwn aekikhphayhlngidphlkhaaennesiyngrwmthnghmdaelw catxngkhanwnhaphlharepnchudsahrbaetlaphrrkhkaremuxng odyichsutrdngni 1 quotient V 2 s 1 displaystyle text quotient frac V 2s 1 dd odythi V aethncanwnkhaaennthnghmdthiphrrkhkaremuxngidrb s aethncanwnthinngsungidrbkarcdsrripaelwsahrbphrrkhkaremuxngnn erimcak 0 sahrbthukphrrkhphrrkhidthiidphlharsungsudcaidthinngip aelacathukkhanwnihm odythasakhntxnedimcnkwacaidkhrbthukthinngwithiewbsetxr aesngt lakuwimidrbrxngwaphrrkhkaremuxngthiidkhaaennesiyngmakkwakhrunghnungcaidthinngekinkhrung aemaetwithithiprbaetngaelwkechnkn 11 twxyang aekikh intwxyangni phulngkhaaenncanwn 230 000 khncatxnglngkhaaennephuxeluxkphuaethn 8 khn odymiphrrkhkaremuxng 4 phrrkh odythng 8 thinngcatxngidrbkarcdsrr odykhaaennesiyngkhxngaetlaphrrkhcatxnghardwy 1 tamdwy 3 aela 5 aelatxiperuxy canwnsuungthisud 8 canwn erimtngaet 100 000 lngmathung 16 000 epnphuchnainaetlathinngsahrbkarepriybethiyb sdmph sdswnthiaethcring intarangthdipaesdngihehncanwnepncudthsniymkhxngaetlaphrrkhkaremuxng odykhanwncaksdswnkhxngkhaaennesiyngtxthinngthimithnghmd echn 100 000 230 000 3 48 rxbkhanwn 1 thinngtxrxb 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 chnathinng twhna phrrkh A phlhar thinngthiidcakrxblasud 100 000 1 33 333 1 33 333 2 20 000 2 20 000 2 20 000 3 14 286 3 3phrrkh B phlhar thinngthiidcakrxblasud 80 000 0 80 000 1 26 667 1 26 667 1 26 667 2 16 000 2 16 000 3 3phrrkh C phlhar thinngthiidcakrxblasud 30 000 0 30 000 0 30 000 0 30 000 1 10 000 1 10 000 1 10 000 1 1phrrkh D phlhar thinngthiidcakrxblasud 20 000 0 20 000 0 20 000 0 20 000 0 20 000 0 20 000 1 6 667 1 1tarangkhanglangaesdngihehnkarkhanwnxyangngay twhar 1 3 5 thinngchna sdswnaethcringphrrkh A 100 000 33 333 20 000 3 3 5phrrkh B 80 000 26 667 16 000 3 2 8phrrkh C 30 000 10 000 6 000 1 1 0phrrkh D 20 000 6 667 4 000 1 0 7rwmthngsin 8 8withiodntnnaetktangkntrngsutrkhanwninkarhaphlhar quotient V s 1 displaystyle left text quotient frac V s 1 right sungemuxichsutrniaethn phrrkh A caidrb 4 thinng inkhnathiphrrkh D imidely sungaesdngihehnthungkhwamidepriybkhxngphrrkhkaremuxngihythikhaaennesiyngmak 1 xangxing aekikh 1 0 1 1 1 2 Lijphart Arend 2003 Degrees of proportionality of proportional representation formulas in Grofman Bernard Lijphart Arend b k Electoral Laws and Their Political Consequences Agathon series on representation 1 Algora Publishing pp 170 179 ISBN 9780875862675 See in particular the section Sainte Lague pp 174 175 For example with three seats a 55 25 20 vote is seen to be more proportionally represented by an allocation of 1 1 1 seats than by 2 1 0 Balinski Michel L Peyton Young 1982 Fair Representation Meeting the Ideal of One Man One Vote New votes to seats system makes elections fairer The Jakarta Post 28 May 2018 subkhnemux 19 April 2019 Ireland s Green Party website House of Lords Reform Draft Bill PDF Cabinet Office May 2011 p 16 PDF Electoral Commission https www electoralcommission org uk sites default files pdf file Distribution of UK MEPs among electoral regions pdf subkhnemux 21 December 2019 Missing or empty title help European Parliament Number of MEPs and Distribution between Electoral Regions United Kingdom and Gibraltar Order 2008 Hansard hansard parliament uk http www europarl europa eu sides getDoc do pubRef EP NONSGML IM PRESS 20070604IPR07417 EN DOC PDF V0 EN amp language EN Missing or empty title help McLean Iain 1 November 2008 Don t let the lawyers do the math Some problems of legislative districting in the UK and the USA Mathematical and Computer Modelling 48 9 1446 1454 doi 10 1016 j mcm 2008 05 025 ISSN 0895 7177 Miller Nicholas R February 2013 Election inversions under proportional representation Annual Meeting of the Public Choice Society New Orleans March 8 10 2013 PDF ekhathungcak https th wikipedia org w index php title withiewbsetxr aesngt lakuw amp oldid 9466831, wikipedia, วิกิ หนังสือ, หนังสือ, ห้องสมุด,
